How to detect fires on moving trains in tunnels

In General

The technology of fire detection systems in tunnels has been developed, and still is developing in the world, particularly in mass transit in tunnels – a technology that is supposed to address a mass evacuation during an emergency event, along with written standards, instructions and recommendations in accordance with technological development and based on the experience of emergency events that had happened in tunnels in the past.

All over the world, underground transportation is increasing, in particular within cities and we are aware of the construction of many tunnels and underground railway stations (trains and metro) all over.

The growing concern about safety in underground transportation systems, exacerbated by recent occurrences of accidents in metro tunnels and train tunnels at a worldwide level, represents a great safety challenge to most of the metro and railway systems and a need to detect fire signals as early as possible.

Early fire detection on a train inside a tunnel is important to bring the passengers safely to their destination.

Therefore, early detection of a fire on a moving train in tunnel, especially before the train stops at an underground station is important for safety reason and it is a critical system that activates (triggers) all other safety systems in case of an emergency event, than it must be more than a sophisticated system that can survive in a harsh environment, detect real alarm and prevent unwanted false alarms.

Moreover, the importance of fire detection systems is critical to carry out a quick and efficient evacuation in order to minimize loss of life.

The goal is to provide the passengers with immediate information (visual and audio) during an emergency event, that will enable them to evacuate quickly and safely from the train to protected areas while allowing operators to handle the event.

Considering that a train usually carries over 1000 passengers in a number of cars.

In order to provide safety for underground transport, different types of equipment are used to allow better supervision and control of the various events that may occur during its operation. Fire detection is the important one, which in metro and railway tunnels may be considered as a complex and challenging issue.

Fire detection on moving trains in tunnels is more complicated inside the tunnel itself. For some reason:

• Fire detection due to the train's speed

• Quality and reliability of the detection system

• double check detection to reduce false alarm

• Detection must cover all sides of the train including the below surface

• Piston effect – forced-air flow inside a tunnel caused by moving train.

There are three (3) options of fire detection on moving trains in tunnels.

1. Fire detection in the train itself

2. Fire detection outside the train at the top of the tunnel

3. Fire detection below a moving train

Type of detection:

1. In the train itself

1.1. Spot detector

1.2. HHSD High Sensitivity Smoke Detection (Aspiration system) **

2. Fire detection inside the tunnel – at the top of tunnel (see figure 1)

2.1. Standard Linear heat sensitivity cable

2.2. Fiber optic sensor cable (DTS – Distributor Temperature Sensing) ***

3. Fire detection below the train (recommended before the train stop at underground station)

3.1. Fiber optic sensor cable – at the railway itself ***

3.2. Thermal camera ****

3.3. Triple IR3 flame detector with video recording *****

Detection response time (at least):

A. Spot detector – 10 – 30 sec

B. HSSD – within 10 sec

C. Linear heat sensor cable – > over 60 sec depend on fire size

D. Fiber optic sensor cable – 10-60 sec depend on fire size (max. sampling time 10 sec)

E. Thermal camera / IR sensor – within 5 sec depend on fire size.

F. Triple IR3 –HD detector – 1 sec

Detecting system description

 ** High Sensitivity Smoke Detection (HSSD) systems are used in active fire protection, consisting of a central detection unit which draws air through a network of pipes to detect smoke. The sampling chamber is based on a laser that detects the presence of smoke particles in air by detecting the light scattered by them in the chamber. HSSD can typically detect smoke before it is visible to the naked eye.

*** Distributed temperature sensing systems (DTS) are fiber optic based on optoelectronic

instruments which measure temperature along the length of the fiber optic sensing cable (up to 10 Km). The unique feature of a distributed temperature sensing system is that it provides a continuous (or distributed) temperature profile along the length of the sensing cable and not at discrete sensing points which must be pre-determined.

The response time to generate alarm event depends on fire size in tunnel. The standards to trigger an alarm at load fire of 5MW are up to 60 sec at wind speed of 3 m/sec.

**** The thermal camera is an intelligent sensor which uses thermal and visual imaging for advanced fire detection, occupancy detection and CCTV.

***** The Triple –IR3-HD flame detector provides ultra-fast response, high performance and reliable detection of all types of fires (visible and non-visible). The detector provides high-definition video imaging of fire event.

זיהוי אש ברכבת נוסעת במנהרה

Figure 1

Fire detection technology that exists today covers the fire detection requirements fairly well in the train itself and in the tunnels. However, the ability to detect fire under a moving train is just as important, as the train proceeds to the underground station.

How to detect fire below the moving train?

Let's say a train with 1000 passengers inside it enters an underground station and under the train a fire is detected.

If so, what are the technological means to detect fire under a moving train in a tunnel?
To answer this question, consider what should be the parameters of choosing the best detection system that exists today:

• Where would be the best location for detecting fire before the train stops at the station

• Speed of the train on that location

• How long it will take for the train to stop

• What is the minimum time to give notice of evacuation at the station?

• What is the best way to provide a reliable fire detection solution?

How long does it take a train to stop ?

Trains can't stop quickly. The average freight train is about 1¼ to 1½ miles (2 – 2.5 Km) in length of 8 car passenger.

The train moves around 50 miles per hour (80 Km/hr.) on that point, and it will take around 3 minutes to stop at the platform.

Note: the data collected from Jerusalem main underground train station, the station is 80 meters underground and connects via 2.5 kilometer tunnel.

Therefore, based on this data we can estimate that 2 Km from the station will be good enough to locate the fire detecting point (check point). And it will be enough time (3 minutes) to start the evacuation procedures at the station, automatically or by the operator.

Recommendations:

Two types of flame and thermal detectors could be used at the check point from both sides of the tunnel (see figure 2).

• Thermal camera with intelligent sensor which uses thermal and visual imaging

• Triple -IR3-HD flame detector provides ultra-fast response that produces high definition video imaging.

In addition, should be used a fiber optic sensor cable at the railway itself along the tunnel.

Launching an automatic evacuation is recommended after receiving alerts from at least two

detectors/sensors.

Figure 2

In conclusion:

To cover all options of fire detection on moving trains in tunnels, it is important to consider all fire detection aspects in order to minimize loss of life.

 

Published and edited by:
Eng. Eliezer Ezra Azaria
BSc, MSM
G1-Group Israel
Ezra.eliezer-azaria@g1-group.com